Another build story
wraithrslib 05 Mar 2012
Pulls like a freight train I'll bet.
Nice one.
Yeah it does! I don't think I need much more for street duties hehe- different story for the track, strip, ect.. though ;-)
cheers
wraithrslib 31 Mar 2012
As it's involved my solicitor and an engineer over the last month. I did contact a few guys on here in the know to help me also with this.
So on feb 25 noon which was a nice sunny day, I had to pic up my son for gymnastics. so I warmed up the car drove of and about two blocks away from home I came up to a rounder bout. So from 3rd gear at about 50kph dropped down to 2nd entering the round about turning right. And I heard several loud clunks which I thought might of been a drive shaft clutch ect..
The engine check light then came on so I then just rolled through the rounder bout instead of turning right.
I came to a stop and got out of the car to see smoke coming out of the drives side guard so I lifted the bonnet to find a lot of oil over the top of the engine and a dirty big hole just behind the alternator.
So at least there was minimal oil on the ground. At this stage it's still in the hands of my solicitor so I won't say to much only that chasers and top torque have been cleared of any fault by my engineer Andrew Enkelman who has had 46 years of engineering experience, 40 years of which were in a professional capacity. So I only had him finally assess the engine 2pm tuesday as this guy is very busy and hard to get hold off and his report will be sent to my solicitor next week. This took place at top torque with me present and his verdict after about an hour or so was a manufacturer flaw of rod number two that caused it to slowly crack and finally breaking.
Which he said intern caused all the rest of the damage and was 100% sure that this is what happened. Which is good to know and worth the money spent to get a more professional opinion as top torque thought the engine had hydrauliced but found no signs of any type of fluid in the bores or damage to the gaskets to support this theory along with other possible theories thrown around like injectors stuck open, failed fuel reg, ecu fault ect..ect..
So my biggest fear was it happening again with the next new motor if we couldn't pin point the reason.
Below are pics of the aftermath It's not a pretty sight so if you've got a weak stomach I'd turn away now
Hole in the block
Close up
From the top looks ok.
Other half of block is fine
Billet crank Iv'e been told looks to be ok. Will still need to get it's alignment checked as well as for cracks
All pistons are fugged except for number 3 and one broken rod and the rest of the rods are bent although one almost looks like its ok
and number 2 piston slightly kissed the valves as that's the one that the rod broke, not to much of a problem thank god.
Piston 1
Piston2
Piston 3 is fine and the rod is still on the crank and looks the best of the rods.
Piston 4
Here's the cylinder head were piston 2 kissed two valves and the other head is fine.
So I got the car back last thur minus engine from chasers and will give the engine bay a good clean and will begin a huge weight reduction program whilst there's no engine as it may take a few months to sort that out. At least the set up while it was running was spot on in terms of combo which gave me zero lag and bucket loads of of boost torque and still retained great top end. Next engine I'll definitely be going M&W CDI, closed deck 2.5 block hopefully with my manley crank if all is good!. More comp say 9 plus and most likely no sleeves as I'll be happy with around the 260 to 270 at the wheels going by how the 240kw felt.
Bits Iv'e salvaged from the engine are my arp custom age 625 plus head studs the hyperflow sump the cosworth oil pump gates racing belt. Also all the engine timing belt tensioner pulleys are all new so I'll use them again as well as the new water pump and my ati super damper is all good also. I will be selling my ID 2000's and buying some ID1000's as mid 200kw will be fine with loads of torque.
cheers wayne
simon 31 Mar 2012
RX25SE 31 Mar 2012
WTF is with fat shot peened rods failing like that? I know they were new but were they crack tested?
So the top end is OK? Looking at piston 2 I am suprised that the inlets are't bent.
How the hell did the other rods bend like that? I can't see how any busted bits of engine would cause that as there is little that I can see on pistons.
Im sure it's not the case but they look as if they bent under serious pressure coming down from the piston. ie massive boost.
Top Torque in Nunawading Melb?
wraithrslib 31 Mar 2012
Shit with a capital S.
WTF is with fat shot peened rods failing like that? I know they were new but were they crack tested?
So the top end is OK? Looking at piston 2 I am suprised that the inlets are't bent.
How the hell did the other rods bend like that? I can't see how any busted bits of engine would cause that as there is little that I can see on pistons.
Im sure it's not the case but they look as if they bent under serious pressure coming down from the piston. ie massive boost.
Top Torque in Nunawading Melb?
Hi yeah to me seems more like a lock up due to water or fuel and the builder said they found nothing in the bores when they cracked it open. So who knows just don't want it to happen again so I'll attempt to cover my butt on as many possibilities as possible with new engine.
Yeah Top Torque in Nunawading Melb, the failure was in decel going into a rounder bout! so off throttle and not even on boost and my tune was only running 19 odd psi.
Any howz not going to waste to much time or energy trying to get compensated will see what my lawyer thinks when he reads the report. just want to get it running as soon as I can.
PS: thnx for the nice replies every one.
cheers wayne
RX25SE 31 Mar 2012
Hi yeah to me seems more like a lock up due to water or fuel and the builder said they found nothing in the bores when they cracked it open. So who knows just don't want it to happen again so I'll attempt to cover my butt on as many possibilities as possible with new engine.
Yeah Top Torque in Nunawading Melb, the failure was in decel going into a rounder bout! so off throttle and not even on boost and my tune was only running 19 odd psi.
Any howz not going to waste to much time or energy trying to get compensated will see what my lawyer thinks when he reads the report. just want to get it running as soon as I can.
PS: thnx for the nice replies every one.
cheers wayne
Butt covering is always a good idea.
I believe the new owner of Top Torque is a good bloke.
RX25SE 01 Apr 2012
New owner? since when?
cheers
Couple of years I believe, its been many since I stopped using them. One of the the employees bougt the business IIRC.
Good thing too.
wraithrslib 25 Oct 2013
Hi all it's been a while since this epic fail but I've been working hard from mid last year after all most selling up everything and letting it drift off into oblivion.
And that's just not in my nature.
So I asked my self what's the best way to resurrect this build and avoid possible things happening again So I decided to do as much of the work my self were I can and so far I have! which allows me to know more at what is going on. Saving money this time around is also a positive thing well the wifie thinks so haha.
So the big question was to keep it on the road or not and I decided that going a dedicated hill climber from hell would be the go and allow me to run any engine plat form I could fit into the beast and bang for buck a stock EG33 big block would mean even in n/a form in the little liberty with E85 would still be a lot to handle for starters.
Oh and these engines are fairly cheap now days which is what I'm thinking in the long term as most engines let go in race trim sooner or later and the big six could make some good grunt without stressing it as much as a new 2.5 bottom end would be.
So after selling of all my four banger related gear I wouldn't need the H6 build I raked in just under 10k!!
Which means the funds are there to do more or less the whole build without extra out lay and doing the labour my self also is a big help! It'll just be slower getting things done.
wraithrslib 25 Oct 2013
wraithrslib 25 Oct 2013
wraithrslib 25 Oct 2013
wraithrslib 25 Oct 2013
Rustyrobertson 25 Oct 2013
was following on rs liberty club, and just fell in love with this build once again here great to see some awesome work being done very very interested in the side pipes